Thanksgiving usually consists of cooking on a level that Jews do every week for Shabbat preparation—soup, salad and all those sides that accompany the main dish.
And while chicken has been a staple from the agricultural era and was never a stranger to kashrut, or kosher standards, the turkey was initially an unknown bird, as it didn’t exist in the Old World, thus presenting a dilemma about whether or not it was acceptable for Jews to eat according to dietary laws.
Although the turkey appeared in Jewish legal literature in the 18th century, the issue surrounding whether or not the New World bird was kosher had been decided primarily because the Mishnah Hullin dealt with new, unfamiliar birds. For kosher certification, birds must consist of specific physiological features: a crop, an extra toe and a muscular, thick-walled part of its stomach that is easy to peel.
Additionally, there is a behavioral requirement in that kosher birds cannot have particular kinds of predatory manners.
Finally, Jews celebrating Thanksgiving in Israel is, like their counterparts in the United States, not frowned upon in that, along with observing Jewish law, Israel consumes double the turkey meat that Americans eat annually.
According to Israel’s Ministry of Agriculture, Israelis eat approximately 28 pounds of turkey every year—almost double the 16.4 pounds eaten annually by the average American.
More than that, nearly half of Israel’s turkey production is exported to Europe.
Shalom from Israel,
My great grandfather a/h was a “shochet” – (ritual slaughterer) in Lithuania and taught the men who wanted to do this job. He declared that Turkeys are TREIF – he said he had seen that sometimes turkeys would hold down their food with their “feet” – which makes it non kosher. Birds of prey hold down their food and therefore are not kosher. So, in my family no one eats turkey. I have met only two other people in my thankfully long life who also do not eat turkey for this reason.
Thanks for your emails.
Shulamith Goodman